1. Home
  2. Breaking

Supreme Court Pulls Up Sanjay Raut Over Remarks on CJI


Supreme Court Pulls Up Sanjay Raut Over Remarks on CJI

The Supreme Court of India issued a stern reminder regarding public accountability and institutional respect during the hearing of a high-profile criminal contempt case. A bench comprising Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi strongly reprimanded Shiv Sena (UBT) Member of Parliament Sanjay Raut, emphasizing that expressions of remorse must be genuine rather than procedural formalities.The proceedings stem from a criminal contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), challenging public statements made by Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle targeting the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and the wider judicial establishment. With Raut appearing in person before the bench, the court examined the gravity of his remarks and subsequent social media conduct."As a Seasoned Politician, You Must Exercise Restraint"During the courtroom exchanges, Justice Aravind Kumar questioned Raut directly about his actions, noting his long-standing career in public life."An apology must come from the heart," Justice Kumar observed. "Sanjay Raut, you are a senior leader. You have been in politics for perhaps 25 years. We have been listening to you in political debates for a long time. What do you have to say about your conduct?"The bench underlined that political figures and individuals with public platforms bear a heightened responsibility to uphold the dignity of constitutional institutions. The court noted that while an unconditional apology was submitted, the intent behind such statements remains critical to judicial evaluation.SCBA Highlights Subsequent Social Media ActivityRepresenting the Supreme Court Bar Association, SCBA President and Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai strongly opposed the leniency sought, arguing that Raut's public behavior reflected a continuous pattern of contempt.Mr. Rai brought to the bench's attention that even after submitting an apology affidavit, Raut continued to share provocative material online. Specifically, the SCBA pointed out a social media post wherein Raut shared an image depicting the Supreme Court of Albania engulfed in flames."Sanjay Raut has apologized, but his conduct has consistently been contemptuous," Rai submitted before the bench. Highlighting that similar contempt matters involving Raut are also pending before the Bombay High Court, the SCBA urged the apex court to deal strictly with repeat infractions that tend to lower the authority of the judiciary.Counsel representing Sanjay Raut maintained that the defense stood on the unconditional and unqualified apology tendered to the court, though the bench directed Raut to file an additional comprehensive affidavit addressing his subsequent online posts.Background of the Contempt ProceedingsThe roots of the controversy trace back to mid-October 2026, when the SCBA moved a criminal contempt petition under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The friction erupted after the Chief Justice of India declined a formal request from an opposition political delegation for a personal meeting, clarifying that administrative or political grievances must be pursued through proper judicial petitions rather than direct representations.Following the decision, public commentary from political figures and commentators escalated. The petition alleged that Sanjay Raut made scurrilous imputations against judges and the administrative functioning of the apex court, while journalist Nikhil Wagle posted controversial remarks on social media platform X (which Wagle later withdrew, expressing unconditional regret through Senior Advocate Indira Jaising).With Attorney General R. Venkataramani having granted statutory consent to initiate criminal contempt action, the Supreme Court has directed both respondents to submit detailed supplementary affidavits. The matter has been scheduled for further hearing, as the judiciary continues to weigh freedom of expression against the legal boundaries protecting institutional integrity.

Around the web